I Loved You While You Were Leaving · Track 10
For when staying connected felt safer than telling the truth, so you kept swallowing your needs until you could barely hear yourself anymore.
Inside this song
Why did keeping the peace feel safer than saying what I actually needed?
Sometimes self-silencing can feel like the safest way to preserve connection, especially when honesty feels likely to create distance or conflict. But keeping someone else comfortable shouldn’t require disappearing from your own relationship. Your needs deserve a voice too.
“Silence was safer than the truth, But I’ve burned through the lies I mistook for proof.”
For when you became so focused on keeping them comfortable that silence slowly became another way of abandoning yourself.
Read the full storyLyric sheet
Verse 1 Silence was safer than truth, I bit my tongue just to comfort you. Held my breath while I drowned inside, Let your shadows cover up my light.
Pre-Chorus I was soft when I should’ve been strong, Kept the peace while I broke all along. You were hiding, I was holding on But love shouldn’t feel like a war you can’t win.
Chorus Silence was safer than the truth, So I carried the weight for the both of us too. You never believed me, never let me in, I swallowed my needs so your child could grin. But I can’t keep bleeding for both of our youth When silence was safer than the truth.
Verse 2 You built your walls, I built a cage, Trading my voice just to calm your rage. I spoke in whispers, you stayed withdrawn, I delayed the ending, pretending we weren’t gone.
Pre-Chorus Every secret screamed in the quiet night, But you shut your eyes instead of fight. I begged with patience, you answered with fear Now I’m screaming the words you refused to hear.
Chorus Silence was safer than the truth, So I carried the weight for the both of us too. You never believed me, never let me in, I swallowed my needs so your child could grin. But I can’t keep bleeding for both of our youth When silence was safer than the truth.
Bridge I loved the boy you never set free, But I lost the woman I needed to be. Your comfort cost me every piece of my fight Now I’m done dimming just to keep you in the light.
Final Chorus Silence was safer than the truth, But I’ve burned through the lies I mistook for proof. You never believed me, so I’ll believe myself, No longer your shadow, no longer your shell. I’m done carrying the weight that was never my youth ‘Cause silence was safer than the truth.
Outro Silence was safer… but it never was love. Truth is the only thing I’m worthy of.
About the song
For when staying connected felt safer than telling the truth, so you kept swallowing your needs until you could barely hear yourself anymore.
The story behind
"Silence Was Safer Than the Truth" is about what happens when you slowly stop telling the truth, not because you're dishonest, but because you're trying to protect someone you love.
For a long time, I ignored my intuition. I could feel that something was wrong, but every time I brought it up, I was reassured that everything was okay. So I questioned myself instead of questioning the situation. Eventually, it felt easier to stay quiet than to risk another conversation that left me feeling unheard.
I started swallowing my needs to keep the peace. I learned how to make myself smaller, softer, and easier to love. I became more concerned with protecting someone else's feelings than listening to my own.
This song isn't just about someone hiding the truth from me. It's also about the ways I hid the truth from myself. I kept believing words over patterns. I kept making excuses for emotional distance. I kept translating silence into hope because the alternative was admitting that the relationship wasn't what I wanted it to be.
One of the hardest parts of loving someone who struggles with vulnerability is that you can spend years trying to understand them while they never truly let you in. You become the one carrying every difficult conversation, every unanswered question, every emotional weight. Eventually, you realize you've been fighting for honesty by yourself.
The line, "I loved the boy you never set free, but I lost the woman I needed to be," is the heart of this song. I had so much compassion for the wounded parts of someone else that I slowly abandoned myself in the process.
Healing taught me something I'll never forget: Peace that depends on your silence isn't peace. Love shouldn't require you to ignore your intuition, suppress your voice, or convince someone to let you in. The right relationship makes honesty feel safe, not dangerous.
This song is about finding my voice again, trusting myself again, and realizing that truth may hurt for a moment, but silence can steal years. Because in the end, I deserved more than surviving on half-truths. I deserved a love where honesty didn't have to be earned.
Community support room
Step into a gentle conversation about what this song brought up for you. Share your story, listen without judgment, and leave a little hope for someone else.
Save your favorite songs and create your own.
Start a playlist →
Lyric journals, apparel, and more.
Shop now →♡A safe space for real conversations.
You are not alone →